All Blacks Legend Accuses Rassie Erasmus of ‘Conspiracy Theory’ on Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry Tour
- The All Blacks’ South African tour has raised fresh questions ahead of their much-anticipated clash with the Springboks in Johannesburg
- A former All Blacks great has now weighed in on the tour, with his comments adding an unexpected twist before Saturday’s Test
- The debate has put the spotlight on South Africa’s approach to the provincial matches and what New Zealand can expect at Ellis Park
PAY ATTENTION: Mark Briefly News as a preferred source, and our content will appear higher in your Google feed!
Source: Getty Images
All Blacks legend John Kirwan has questioned Rassie Erasmus’ approach to the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry tour, suggesting the New Zealanders may not have encountered the full Springbok challenge in their provincial matches.
Speaking on the Rugby Rivals podcast, Kirwan raised what he described as a “conspiracy theory” surrounding the way the South African sides approached their matches against New Zealand.
“I think it’s a bit more of a conspiracy theory out there,” Kirwan said as reported by SA Rugby Magazine.
“Rassie has told those provincial sides not to play anything like the Springboks.”
PAY ATTENTION: You can now search for all your favourite news and topics on Briefly News.
He pointed to the absence of tactics such as high kicks, kicking for the corner and maul pressure.
“It’s pretty sad for the relationship and for the tour,” Kirwan added. “I get it, I would do exactly the same if I was Rassie and not release the players.”
Victor Matfield defends the Springboks boss
Matfield pushed back on the suggestion that the provincial teams could simply have produced a closer preview of the Springboks. He highlighted the inexperience in the Sharks side, saying:
“They were kids; there were probably three guys who were still at school last year. A really young team with no experience.”
He also pointed to the Bulls’ second-half improvement after Johan Grobbelaar and Elrigh Louw entered the contest, saying the difference was clear once greater experience was added.
The All Blacks defeated the Stormers, Sharks and Vodacom Bulls during the tour. Matfield also highlighted South Africa’s changing provincial depth, saying it was not comparable with 15 or 20 years ago.
Source: Getty Images
Kirwan believes more players could have featured
Kirwan acknowledged why Erasmus may have wanted to keep his key players fresh for the Test. However, he believed the Springboks boss could have made greater use of the wider squad during the provincial matches.
With 44 players in the touring group and only 23 able to feature in a Test match, Kirwan felt there was room to expose more squad members to the All Blacks without compromising the main Test preparations.
“I reckon you could take a bit more of a risk with” some of those players, he said.
The discussion now shifts from the provincial games to the main event. The Springboks will face the All Blacks at Ellis Park on Saturday, 22 August 2026, with New Zealand set to encounter a far more experienced South African line-up.
Springboks keep Test plans under wraps
Briefly News also reported that Rassie Erasmus is taking his time before confirming his Springboks squad for the All Blacks series, with the announcement scheduled for Thursday, 20 August 2026.
The Springboks boss has chosen not to reveal his selections yet, keeping New Zealand in the dark as the first Test at Ellis Park draws closer.
The move comes as attention remains firmly on how both teams have approached preparations for Saturday’s showdown.
PAY ATTENTION: Follow Briefly News on Twitter and never miss the hottest topics! Find us at @brieflyza!
Source: Briefly News
