World Cup: The Controversial Decision to Send Off Themba Zwane vs Mexico, How Fans Reacted

• Bafana Bafana struggled in their opening match at the 2026 FIFA World Cup against Mexico, losing 2-0 on Thursday evening
• One of the biggest talking points of the game was Themba Zwane's red card in the second half after Sphephelo Sithole was also sent off
• The reason behind the Mamelodi Sundowns attacking midfielder's sending off has been explained, with fans also sharing their thoughts

A nine-man Bafana Bafana side suffered a 2–0 defeat to 2026 FIFA World Cup co-hosts Mexico in the opening match of the tournament at the Estadio Azteca on Thursday, June 11, 2026.

Goals from Julián Quiñones and Raúl Jiménez secured maximum points for the hosts, who delivered a commanding performance under Javier Aguirre.

Hugo Broos set up his team in a compact 5-3-2 formation, clearly prioritising defensive solidity while keeping two strikers forward to exploit counter-attacking opportunities.

Bafana Bafana were reduced to 10 players shortly after the restart when Sithole received a straight red card for a last-man foul on Brian Gutiérrez in the 49th minute.

Read also

Explained: The incident behind Sphephelo Sithole’s sending-off vs Mexico

The situation deteriorated further in the closing stages as South Africa ended the match with nine men after substitute Themba Zwane was dismissed for an off-the-ball incident following a VAR review, capping a disappointing outing in which Bafana failed to trouble the Mexican side.

Why Zwane was sent off

According to the rules of the game, Zwane's hitting the Mexican player on the face after passing the ball is seen as violent conduct, and in today's game, it is given as a red card.

The Mamelodi Sundowns midfielder is expected to miss South Africa's next group game against the Czech Republic, but his World Cup campaign could be over if the FIFA disciplinary committee impose more punishment on the Premier Soccer League veteran.

What fans are saying about Zwane's red card

Here is what fans are saying on social media about the red card shown to Zwane after playing just 23 minutes.

Read also

Video: Siya Kolisi and Springboks back Bafana Bafana at 2026 World Cup

Denzyl said:

"This ref is joking, it's pointless!!! The first goal for Mexico was clearly offside before the foul was committed, and no intervention. Now, suddenly, they want to get involved when a Mexican player clearly fouled Zwane."

Mo Bongoluv shared:

"You should review or protest that red Card cos how was he supposed to play, since the Mexican player was blocking him?"

Sdi-t Ncwane wrote:

"Hand on the opponent's face is a red card."

Xolavas Elsharawy implied:

"I think they have to review this rule because it wasn't a clear slap; a yellow card was enough."

Farm. Inspo commented:

"Disadvantages of playing in a league that has no VAR, he thought he could get away with it."

Jay Steps added:

"The red card, I think, should be awarded for such an act on the field. It looks like a deliberate act, with a "hand" in a "football" game. A tackle/kick/step would've made it lighter and got a Yellow card for dangerous foul play."

Read also

Mexico coach says ‘I hate you’ before predicting major move for Relebohile Mofokeng

Bafana players face costly World Cup discipline rules

Briefly News previously reported that Bafana Bafana players could face more than just suspensions if they lose their discipline at the 2026 FIFA World Cup.

FIFA's latest disciplinary code reportedly imposes fines of US$10,000 (about R165,000) for a yellow card, US$15,000 (about R248,000) for an indirect red card and US$20,000 (about R330,000) for a straight red card.

Source: Briefly News