Online hate sows Muslim fears as India votes

Online hate sows Muslim fears as India votes

The mother of Faheem Qureshi, who was killed in anti-Muslim riots in February, sits with a picture of her son
The mother of Faheem Qureshi, who was killed in anti-Muslim riots in February, sits with a picture of her son. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

After his brother was murdered in anti-Muslim riots, Pervez Qureshi watched the videos he believes incited the killers, part of a wave of hatred being fomented on social media ahead of India's elections.

India has a long and grim history of sectarian clashes between the Hindu majority and its biggest minority faith, but analysts warn increasingly available modern technology is being used to deliberately exploit divisions.

"Videos and messages were shared on Facebook and WhatsApp which contained inflammatory language and incitement to violence," Qureshi told AFP, recalling the attack on his brother Faheem in February in the northern city of Haldwani in Uttarakhand state.

"It poisoned the atmosphere."

Nearly 550 million more Indians have access to the internet than when Prime Minister Narendra Modi came to power a decade ago, according to figures from the Internet and Mobile Association of India.

Read also

Ghost in the machine: Deepfake tools warp India election

Modi's Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is widely expected to win a third term in elections that begin on April 19.

After his brother was murdered in anti-Muslim riots, Pervez Qureshi watched the videos he believes incited the killers
After his brother was murdered in anti-Muslim riots, Pervez Qureshi watched the videos he believes incited the killers. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

Part of his popularity can be attributed to his party's masterful online campaign team, staffed by thousands of volunteers who champion his good deeds and achievements.

Modi's use of social media "awakens nationalism and patriotism among the youth in every corner of the country", said Manish Saini, a youth leader of a BJP "IT Cell" in Uttarakhand state, who works online to reach voters.

'Atmosphere of hatred'

A girl rides a bicycle past a charred vehicle belonging to a local Muslim family burnt during the anti-Muslim riots in February
A girl rides a bicycle past a charred vehicle belonging to a local Muslim family burnt during the anti-Muslim riots in February. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

Critics however accuse the BJP's sophisticated social media apparatus of also fanning the flames of division.

Haldwani community leader Islam Hussain said tensions were already high before February's violence, after months of incendiary social media posts calling Muslims "outsiders".

"It was said that due to the increasing population of Muslims, the social demography of Uttarakhand is changing", Hussein said.

Read also

Smuggled Starlink dishes throw lifeline to some in war-torn Sudan

"Right-wing social media cells have a big role in creating an atmosphere of hatred against Muslims."

Clashes erupted after the authorities said a mosque had been built illegally, and a Muslim group gathered to prevent its demolition.

Some hurled stones at police officers, who beat them back with batons and tear gas.

Hindu residents gathered to cheer on the police clampdown, chanting religious slogans and throwing rocks at the crowd.

Footage of the riots spread swiftly on social media.

Egged on by online calls to mobilise, Hindu mobs rampaged through the streets.

Faheem Qureshi was killed in anti-Muslim riots in February in India's Uttarakhand state
Faheem Qureshi was killed in anti-Muslim riots in February in India's Uttarakhand state. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

"It's time to teach them a lesson," read the caption to one of dozens of inflammatory posts, many of which remain online.

"The time has come to beat Muslims."

Qureshi said his brother Faheem, 32, was killed by Hindu neighbours after they first torched his car.

'Triggers an incident'

Youth leader of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party 'IT Cell' in Uttarakhand state Manish Saini said the online team he leads does not encourage violence
Youth leader of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party 'IT Cell' in Uttarakhand state Manish Saini said the online team he leads does not encourage violence. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

But Saini, coordinator for the BJP's youth wing, said the online team he leads does not encourage violence -- and is under strict instruction not to "write anything against anyone's religion".

Read also

Colombia guerrillas lure youth on TikTok

He said his colleagues had mobilised quickly on the day riots broke out to provide information, not to stir up trouble.

"When we got the news, we immediately started preparing graphics, videos and text messages to reach people with the correct and accurate information related to the incident," he said.

He said the initial violence was clashes between police and a Muslim group -- and blamed Modi's opponents for instigating riots to tarnish the government's image.

Critics disagree.

Parvez Qureshi stands beside an autorickshaw burnt during the violence in front of his house
Parvez Qureshi stands beside an autorickshaw burnt during the violence in front of his house. Photo: Amarjeet Kumar SINGH / AFP
Source: AFP

Raqib Hameed Naik, from research group Hindutva Watch, said that the BJP's IT Cell had generated anger towards minorities, by promoting the government's Hindu-nationalist agenda.

Naik, who documents hate speech against religious minorities, said the social media messages spreading during the Haldwani violence followed a pattern seen in previous riots.

"First, hate speech against Muslims by a Hindu activist or politician creates an atmosphere... then the hate speech triggers an incident," Naik said.

Read also

'Grave step backwards': Meta shuts monitoring tool in election year

Afterwards, online Hindu-nationalist campaigners "hold Muslims responsible" for the violence, he added.

Source: AFP

Authors:
AFP avatar

AFP AFP text, photo, graphic, audio or video material shall not be published, broadcast, rewritten for broadcast or publication or redistributed directly or indirectly in any medium. AFP news material may not be stored in whole or in part in a computer or otherwise except for personal and non-commercial use. AFP will not be held liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions in any AFP news material or in transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages whatsoever. As a newswire service, AFP does not obtain releases from subjects, individuals, groups or entities contained in its photographs, videos, graphics or quoted in its texts. Further, no clearance is obtained from the owners of any trademarks or copyrighted materials whose marks and materials are included in AFP material. Therefore you will be solely responsible for obtaining any and all necessary releases from whatever individuals and/or entities necessary for any uses of AFP material.