'Not ready': Taiwan reservists stoic but unprepared for China threat

'Not ready': Taiwan reservists stoic but unprepared for China threat

Taiwanese army reservist Henry Cheng says his four months of military training felt more like 'play' than an experience that prepared him for combat
Taiwanese army reservist Henry Cheng says his four months of military training felt more like 'play' than an experience that prepared him for combat. Photo: Asnaya Chou / AFP
Source: AFP

New feature: Check out news exactly for YOU ➡️ find “Recommended for you” block and enjoy!

Sitting pensively in a pew at a Taipei church, army reservist Henry Cheng is nonchalant about the Chinese warships and jets circling his island -- but he also feels ill-prepared for war.

China's massive military drills this month pushed tensions in the Taiwan Strait to their highest point in years, deepening fears Beijing could forcibly take control of the self-ruled democracy it claims as its own.

Coming on the heels of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the crisis has revived debate within Taiwan and among key Western allies about the readiness of the island's vastly outnumbered military.

But Cheng said he was unconcerned.

"It was like 'Oh, they're at it again,'" the 25-year-old insurance sales agent told AFP. "They've been talking about a war since I was little but there still hasn't been one."

Read also

Could Ukraine assassinate in Russia? Maybe, but doubtful

Cheng completed his mandatory four-month military service last year, placing him in the ranks of some 2.5 million reservists who could be called up to battle if an invasion took place.

PAY ATTENTION: Follow Briefly News on Twitter and never miss the hottest topics! Find us at @brieflyza!

Yet conflict feels like a distant reality for Cheng compared to his usual routine of meeting clients and rehearsing Christian worship songs as a drummer for his church band.

"I'm definitely not ready (for war), because four months to me is more like going there to play," he said, referencing his training.

"I'd probably die very quickly. I'll face it when it comes."

'Too short'

Taiwan has increased purchases of jets and anti-ship missiles in recent years but remains massively outgunned by China
Taiwan has increased purchases of jets and anti-ship missiles in recent years but remains massively outgunned by China. Photo: Sam Yeh / AFP
Source: AFP

Mandatory service used to be deeply unpopular in Taiwan, which was once a brutal military dictatorship but has since morphed into a progressive democracy.

Taiwan's previous government reduced compulsory service from one year to four months with the aim of creating a mainly volunteer force.

Read also

Indian tycoon's bid for broadcaster stokes media freedom worries

But Beijing's sabre-rattling has grown more intense under President Xi Jinping, China's most authoritarian leader in a generation.

And Russia's invasion of Ukraine has shown the deadly risks of a giant authoritarian neighbour's verbal threats becoming real.

As a result, President Tsai Ing-wen's administration is exploring whether to reinstate tougher military service.

It is not clear yet when a decision might be made, but polling shows more than three-quarters of the Taiwanese public now believe the length of service is too short.

Taiwan remains massively outgunned by China, with 88,000 ground forces compared to China's one million, according to Pentagon estimates.

But the mountainous island would still present a formidable challenge.

Taipei has stepped up reservist training and increased purchases of jets and anti-ship missiles. But experts say it is not enough.

"I truly believe four months is too short," said Joseph Hwang, associate professor at Taiwan's National Defense University.

Read also

Auld reekie: Edinburgh bin strike leaves a bad smell

"Taiwan has no condition for voluntary military service whatsoever."

Peter Yang, an engineer who plays wargames in his spare time, remembers much of his compulsory military service was mostly "spent doing paperwork".

"There was not a lot of time spent on training, just basic physical training and shooting practice," the 24-year-old told AFP

"Our job is really just to die on the battlefield... so it's enough for us to know how to fire a gun," he said, adding reservists were given only 12 bullets for each shooting practice.

Last month, former US army chief Mark Esper called for Taiwan to triple its mandatory service to a year and extend its enrolment to women.

'Dancing, drinking, exercising'

Some former soldiers believe Taiwan's population may not have the stomach for the type of die-hard resistance Ukraine has shown since Russia's invasion
Some former soldiers believe Taiwan's population may not have the stomach for the type of die-hard resistance Ukraine has shown since Russia's invasion. Photo: Sam Yeh / AFP
Source: AFP

American and Taiwanese strategists have pushed Taipei to adopt a "porcupine" strategy of asymmetric warfare like Ukraine to defend against a Chinese invasion.

But Taiwan's population is not ready for the die-hard resistance seen in the streets of Ukraine's cities, said retired air force colonel Richard Chou, who served for 21 years.

Read also

Songs of praise: Rohingya sing Myanmar anthem 5 years after exodus

"Taiwan's military preparation from my perspective is not enough," the 52-year-old said, adding he would serve willingly if called back.

"It's not only about one person holding a rifle. They also have to learn how to handle situations together as a group through training –- only then will they have a hope of resisting in the future."

To demonstrate how unmoved the Taiwanese are by the threat, 75-year-old veteran Jasper Lee points around a central Taipei park.

"They just had the military exercise around Taiwan island and the people are like this -- dancing, drinking, exercising," he said.

But underneath the stoicism, fears of China linger for many.

John Chen, a 26-year-old reservist, said the drills have increased his anxiety, comparing Beijing to a stalker.

"This person really likes you, but he keeps saying you belong to him... he knows where you go to work every day and follows you home from work. This is the situation that Taiwan is in," he said.

Read also

On Ukraine's front line, no end in sight

"I'm worried about whether my country will continue to exist."

New feature: check out news exactly for YOU ➡️ find "Recommended for you" block and enjoy!

Source: AFP

Authors:
AFP avatar

AFP AFP text, photo, graphic, audio or video material shall not be published, broadcast, rewritten for broadcast or publication or redistributed directly or indirectly in any medium. AFP news material may not be stored in whole or in part in a computer or otherwise except for personal and non-commercial use. AFP will not be held liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions in any AFP news material or in transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages whatsoever. As a newswire service, AFP does not obtain releases from subjects, individuals, groups or entities contained in its photographs, videos, graphics or quoted in its texts. Further, no clearance is obtained from the owners of any trademarks or copyrighted materials whose marks and materials are included in AFP material. Therefore you will be solely responsible for obtaining any and all necessary releases from whatever individuals and/or entities necessary for any uses of AFP material.