"Cheaper to Buy From": Calls to Ban Shein and Temu in SA Met by Fierce Debate

• COSATU officially endorsed a campaign to ban Chinese online retailers Shein and Temu from South Africa
• A study found that international online retailers contributed to the loss of nearly 8,100 jobs between 2020 and 2024
• South Africans are divided, with many defending the platforms as the only affordable shopping option available to them

A TikTok creator known as @ejv_27 has stirred up a heated conversation online after breaking down growing union calls to ban Shein and Temu in South Africa, and the response from everyday shoppers has been telling.

The Congress of South African Trade Unions COSATU made the announcement at its 15th National Congress, where delegates backed a resolution to campaign for the removal of the two Chinese online retail giants from the local market. COSATU said the goal was to protect local businesses and stimulate job creation. The resolution echoed an earlier call from the Southern African Clothing and Textile Workers' Union SACTWU.

Read also

“It’s free”: American expat says two National SA systems are more advanced than the US

The jobs behind the debate

A study by the Localisation Support Fund found that international online retailers were linked to the loss of nearly 8,100 manufacturing and retail jobs between 2020 and 2024. In a worst-case scenario, that figure could climb to more than 34,000 affected jobs by 2030.

Michael Lawrence, executive director of the National Clothing Retail Federation, acknowledged that job losses were real but cautioned against a blanket ban. He described the union's call as "a one-dimensional response to a multidimensional problem," adding that South Africa needed to address the root causes rather than simply shut the platforms down.

Part of the problem has been a tax loophole that allowed low-value imports under R500 to attract a flat 20% duty and zero VAT, compared to the standard 45% duty plus 15% VAT that applies to clothing imports. SARS began closing that loophole in August 2024, though industry players have questioned whether those changes have been effectively enforced.

Read also

Cape Town man says South Africans earn 4 times less than overseas peers for same work

Shein has operated in South Africa for several years, while Temu only officially launched locally in January 2024.

View the TikTok video below:

South Africans split on the ban

For many South Africans, the prospect of a ban cuts close to home. In the comments section of EJV's TikTok video, opinions were strong on both sides:

@Panda49 wrote:

"Why don't SA provide the same shopping experience here? Our shops are too expensive Truworths, Woolworths, Miladys, Bash."

@Chris-Leigh said:

"This is the only place where you will find affordable clothing that fits your body type properly."

@Tobias commented:

"Start by banning the tax on tax on tax."

@Fakhrud-Deen added:

"With this fuel prices online shopping is our best bet free delivery."

@ColeneJordaan pointed out:

"Meanwhile what you buy in shops locally, you read on the label, 'made in china' who is fooling who?"

@user381808825951 said:

"Temu and Shein are cheaper to buy from, local is very expensive."

More Briefly News stories on online and shopping

Read also

More than 500,000 SA jobs at risk as US trade tensions deepen

• A TikTok video showing sister wives grocery shopping and cooking together sparks debate in South Africa, as viewers weigh whether peaceful polygamy is possible.
• NSFAS online applications are open for the 2027 study, with eligible students receiving tuition, accommodation and living-cost support. Deadline: 31 October 2026.
• A Three Anchor Bay Victorian duplex listed for R10.5 million went viral on TikTok, prompting debate over Cape Town property prices and local affordability.

Source: Briefly News