Benni McCarthy Addresses Fat Shaming Comments, Speaks on Issue With Bobby Motaung

Benni McCarthy Addresses Fat Shaming Comments, Speaks on Issue With Bobby Motaung

  • South African football legend Benni McCarthy has broken his silence concerning the fat-shaming comments levelled against him during his time in England
  • The former Bafana Bafana striker, who currently works as the Kenyan men's national team coach, shared his comments on his newly released book
  • The former West Ham United forward also opened up on the issue between him and Kaizer Chiefs board member Bobby Motaung

Bafana Bafana legend Benni McCarthy has finally come out to address the period in his career when a British sports writer publicly body-shamed him during his spell in the English Premier League with West Ham United.

Benni McCarthy looks on during Manchester United's FA Cup clash with Fulham United.
Benni McCarthy during his time with Manchester United ahead of their FA Cup tie against Fulham at Old Trafford. Photo: Michael Regan
Source: Getty Images

The former Orlando Pirates striker has now released his debut autobiography, Benni, offering an unfiltered account of the triumphs and setbacks that shaped his journey in professional football.

The memoir, which includes a specially penned foreword by former Real Madrid manager Jose Mourinho, has officially been published and is currently available in bookstores as well as through online retailers.

Read also

Motaung opens up on Kaizer Chiefs’ signing of Bafana Bafana legend

After retiring from professional football, he has worked as an assistant manager with Manchester United under the leadership of Erik ten Hag, and he currently manages the Kenyan national team.

McCarthy opens up on body-shaming comments

In his memoir, McCarthy, just like Oswin Appollis, shared his rise from playing so-called “gangster football” in Cape Town’s Cape Flats to starring for major clubs across Europe.

In 2010, shortly after joining West Ham, he sustained a serious knee ligament injury that would significantly derail his career. Sidelined from matches and training, the striker began to gain weight.

Having consistently maintained a playing weight of around 80kg throughout most of his professional career, McCarthy admitted he soon found himself four to five kilograms heavier and battling to secure a place in a team fighting relegation.

With results deteriorating and McCarthy’s fitness under scrutiny, compounded by repeated fines linked to weight issues, criticism mounted rapidly.

West Ham vice-chairperson and media personality Karren Brady used her column in The Sun to lambast McCarthy's physical condition.

Among her cutting remarks were claims that instead of signing a prolific scorer, the club had brought in someone more focused on “filling his belly than filling the net,” adding that despite later efforts to slim down, he had crossed “the waistline of no return.”

Read also

Rugby player dies in tragic accident enroute to training

In the book, McCarthy describes the commentary as unnecessarily cruel. When approached for a response, he retaliated with an insult that dominated headlines.

McCarthy on tension with Motaung

McCarthy also addressed the condescending comment made about him by Kaizer Chiefs board member Bobby Motaung after he was being linked with a move back to the Premier Soccer League in 2011, after terminating his contract with the Hammers.

Motaung made a public statement dismissing reports linking McCarthy to the Glamour Boys by claiming that Amakhosi signs “big fish,” not those who “cannot swim anymore.”

Bafana Bafana legend & Kenya coach Benni McCarthy hits out at 'ambitionless South African players'.
Coach Benni McCarthy reacts at the end of the pre-season friendly match between Manchester United and Rayo Vallecano at Old Trafford. Photo: Ash Donelon.
Source: Getty Images

McCarthy, in his autobiography, wrote that such comments fuelled his competitive fire, reinforcing his determination to prove doubters wrong; it also motivated him to sign for Chiefs’ rivals, Orlando Pirates.

He would later enjoy notable derby victories over Kaizer Chiefs, taking particular satisfaction in one emphatic win. The Bafana Bafana legend recounts telling Motaung after the match that as long as he wore Pirates colours, Chiefs would not defeat them, a pointed response to the earlier “old fish” remark. Motaung eventually issued an apology.

Read also

England rugby legend reveals why Springboks can handle setbacks better than most

Chiefs, Pirates, Sundowns battle for SA forward

Briefly News also reported that Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates and Mamelodi Sundowns are in a transfer battle as they are all interested in snapping up a South African forward.

The three PSL giants were said to be looking for the possibility of signing the winger before the winter transfer window closes.

Source: Briefly News

Authors:
Raphael Abiola avatar

Raphael Abiola (Sports editor) Raphael Abiola is a Nigerian Sports Journalist with over seven years of experience. He obtained a B.Tech degree in Computer Science from the Federal University of Technology, Akure, in 2015. Raphael previously worked as a football editor at Stakegains (2016-2018) and a content editor with Opera News Nigeria (2018-2023). Raphael then worked as an Editor for the Local Desk at Sports Brief (2023-2024). Reach him via email at raphael.abiola@briefly.co.za.